Should Amazon let brands decide who can join their Creator Connections campaigns? I floated that idea, and a bronze/silver influencer pushed back hard. She makes some great points, so I want to walk through her pushback and where I think the real problem sits.

In this article

The Real Problem Isn’t Free Samples

A lot of the Creator Connections debate gets stuck on free product samples. In my view that is not the real issue. The deeper problem is how the system rewards creators for claiming campaigns, whether or not they ever promote the product.

Halo Sales and Grabbing Every Campaign

Halo sales are the incentive. When a shopper clicks your link and buys other things, you earn on those too, so creators are pushed to claim every campaign they can. It is rational behavior, and it is exactly why campaigns fill up fast.

Brands Paying for Zero Promotion

The side effect lands on brands. They end up paying commissions on a campaign that attracted creators who never promoted the product at all. That is a broken deal for the brand, and brands notice. Some even ask creators to leave campaigns.

Why Brand Approval Is Hard for Off-Site Creators

This is where the viewer’s pushback is strong. Brand approval would slow things down, and that is tough for creators who post fast off-site. If you create quickly and need to move while a trend is hot, waiting on a brand to approve you can cost you the window.

Could Bronze and Silver Creators Get Cut Out?

She also raised a long-running theory: that Creator Connections could eventually cut out bronze and silver creators. I can’t say whether that will happen, but I understand why people worry about it, and it is part of why brand approval feels threatening to smaller creators. I also cover how halo sales on-site and possible Amazon changes play into this.

Creator Connections Needs a Structural Fix

My takeaway is that Creator Connections needs a structural fix, not a patch. Whatever Amazon does, it has to deal with the incentive to claim everything without promoting, while not punishing creators who actually put in the work.

  • Claim campaigns you will genuinely create content for, not every one on the list.
  • Treat brand relationships as long-term, since brands can and do ask creators to leave.
  • Diversify beyond a single program so a rule change doesn’t wipe out your income.

To spend your effort on the right products, use Oink for Influencers. It is built to help Amazon influencers and affiliates find great products to make content for, so the campaigns and products you choose are ones you will actually promote. Check it out at oinkforinfluencers.com.

Find your next winning product with Oink for Influencers.

Similar Posts