A new Amazon influencer asked me to audit her storefront, and I ran into a number I had never seen before: only 36% of her last 50 videos had products that were actually selling. That one number explains more about her commissions than anything else in the audit.
I walked through the whole thing on video, and in this post I’ll break down what I look at, what the numbers mean, and what I told her to change. If you want me to audit yours, the same process applies. Product first, creation second, competition third.
In this article:
- Step 1: The Product Selection Audit
- The Clothing Problem and Upper Carousels
- Step 2: Video Production Best Practices
- Step 3: Competing for Clicks
- What to Fix First
- Run This Audit on Your Own Storefront
Step 1: The Product Selection Audit
The first thing I do is run a tool I built that scans your storefront, pulls the last 50 videos you made, and pulls the products from those videos. It gives me a snapshot of whether you are picking winning or losing products.
Here is what her numbers looked like and how I read them:
- Videos with sales: 36%. This is the red flag. Only 36% of her last 50 videos had products likely to make her money. I want this number up around 80%. Nothing else in the audit matters if this part does not get fixed.
- Videos with Creator Connections campaigns: 60%. Not terrible, but I would rather see 75 to 80%. It tells me she is playing in the Creator Connections playground without making it a priority.
- Average price of selling products: $26. A little low. I would like to see $35 to $40, but there is nothing actionable here. I do not put much weight on price.
- Average monthly units when a product sells: about 2,600. My usual benchmark is 2,500 to 3,500, so when she picks a winner, it is a good one. She just is not picking winners often enough.
- Videos with upper carousels: 25%. This is a problem, and it comes down to clothing.
- Products with sales history: 27%. Same story as the first number. Too many products that are not selling.
Remember the basic rule: if a product is not selling, Amazon is not making money, which means Amazon is not paying you commissions. That is why we target products that are selling.
The Clothing Problem and Upper Carousels
A lot of her videos were clothing, and after the recent Amazon influencer commission rate drops, clothing took a big hit. Without Creator Connections on top, she is not making much per video.
The other issue is that clothing does not get upper carousels on Amazon. Upper carousels will always convert better than lower carousels. If there is no upper carousel, every clothing video makes the buyer scroll way down the page to find you. They just do not convert as well.
If your whole goal is Amazon influencer commission, clothing is probably not the path forward. If you post clothing content somewhere else first and just put it on your storefront as a bonus, that is a different story. But if commissions are the goal, I would rather see you focus on home goods, vacuum cleaners, flashlights, sporting equipment, or basically any category except clothing, shoes, and jewelry.
One more number: when there is an upper carousel, she was competing against 4.91 influencers on average. Remember, the carousel only holds five. That is higher than most, and it is another reason to lean on Creator Connections products.
Step 2: Video Production Best Practices
Next I look at how the videos are made. These were my notes for her:
- Orientation: Keep doing clothing in vertical, since it seems to do well. For home goods and other products, shoot horizontal. Most high-level Amazon influencers focus on horizontal first.
- Open with the buyer, not yourself: She started many videos with a personal intro. Instead, meet the buyer at the door. Say the question they are already asking: does this lotion actually work, do animals actually like this, is this kit worth it? If they do not feel like you know what they want, they will go watch someone else’s video.
- Skip the voiceovers: She was great on camera and very natural. Voiceover videos are the easiest to steal. A video thief can drop their own voice over yours. Talking to the camera is also more personable.
- Get a lavalier mic: Some of her audio was echoey. Every creator needs a wireless lav mic, around $40, and should use it on every video. If your video is worth making, it is worth making well.
- Demonstrate the product: If it is a nail product, put it on your nail. Show the product doing the thing it was designed to do, because that is one of the biggest reasons people are watching.
Step 3: Competing for Clicks
Every video you make goes on a product page where another influencer is competing for the same clicks. You have two visual tools to win them: the thumbnail and the title.
Her thumbnails were already great. She made an individual picture with the product front and center, so anyone scrolling the carousel knows exactly what the video is about.
Titles are where you reconnect with the buyer. Compare these: “pocket beard comb” is an awful title. “Beard comb, amazing gift idea” does not do anything. But “only one thing I don’t like about this beard care set” creates mystery and makes me want to click. Ask a question, promise an answer, and give them a reason to click.
What to Fix First
If I had to boil the audit down to a priority list:
- Get the share of videos with selling products up toward 80%.
- Focus on Creator Connections products to raise commissions per video.
- Move away from clothing if commissions are the goal.
- Open videos by asking the buyer’s question out loud.
- Use a lav mic, talk to the camera, and demonstrate the product in action.
Fix the first one before anything else. You can have perfect thumbnails and great audio, but a product that does not sell will not pay you.
Run This Audit on Your Own Storefront
The product research side of this is exactly what I built Oink to help with. It shows you sales history, Creator Connections availability, and carousel data right on the Amazon page so you can pick winning products before you make the video. Check it out at Oink for Influencers and stop guessing which products are worth your time.